‘Cannot register duplicate name ‘XXX’ in this scope’ in VS 2010

Here’s a gotcha that was puzzling me yesterday.

I’ve just installed Visual Studio 2010 RC, and was trying it out on my current project. It’s a Silverlight Navigation-style project, but that’s not important to the bug.

I found one page where the Xaml designer wouldn’t handle the page properly – it was throwing exceptions, and the editor was showing an error in the Xaml. The line looked like this:


<local:SimpleConverter x:Name="SimpleConverter"/>

This is a value converter, designed to convert bindings from one type to another. The error it was showing was ‘Cannot register duplicate name ‘SimpleConverter’ in this scope’. This foxed me for a while – I thought perhaps because I was throwing exceptions when I didn’t recognise the type being converted, but even removing that and simplifying didn’t remove the error.

Then I noticed the key word in the error message: ‘Name’.

In Xaml you can use x:Name if you want something in the Xaml linked up to a class variable in your code-behind. But that was clearly causing issues with whatever the designer was doing behind the scenes. However, if you don’t need code-behind access (as I don’t in this case) you can use x:Key – and that’s the usual mechanism for naming resources.

Changing the resource to:


<local:SimpleConverter x:Key="SimpleConverter"/>

then the errors from the visual designer stop happening.

Of course, I’ve no idea if the errors are a bug in the designer, or if it’s just wrong to use x:Name in resources, but since I didn’t need the autowiring up of objects, it’s no problem to change it.

Advertisements

23 comments

  1. It should be so obvious… but it isn’t. I’m glad this was number one on my search, it could have eaten a lot of time for something so stupid. Thanks!

  2. Awesome man. Thanks I was trying to solve this issue since last week and I was going crazy. 😦
    Thank you very muchh .. 😀
    Respect \m/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s